31 Oct

More and more younger Canadians wrestling with debt anxiety, survey suggests

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

Younger Canadians tend to be more worried about their personal debt levels amid progressively higher costs, according to a recent Equifax Canada poll.

Approximately 52% of respondents in the 18-34 age range reported anxiety about their personal debt levels, a markedly higher share than the overall average of 39% of other respondents, Equifax said.

More than one-third (36%) of young adults said that they missed a bill payment this year, versus 23% of all other respondents.

“Canadian consumers are concerned about their ability to pay their bills on time, manage their debt, and protect their personal financial data,” Equifax said. “Nearly half of those surveyed indicated that they have never received financial education.”

While 45% of respondents are worried about paying off debt such as mortgagesand student loans, only 18% have sought professional advice or counselling for debt management. Younger adults were also more likely (42%) to get their financial knowledge via social media compered to all other demographics (22%).

“Financial education is an essential building block towards financial resilience to help people make informed financial decisions and protect their well-being,” said Julie Kuzmic, senior compliance officer for consumer advocacy at Equifax Canada. “We need to talk about money more to empower Canadians of all ages and backgrounds to build financial resilience.”

Data security should be more of a priority

An estimated 32% of respondents said that they never check their credit reports, a mechanism that Equifax Canada described as an effective way to spot the tell-tale signs of identity theft.

“Among younger adults (aged 18-34), 32% believe they are unlikely to become victims of identity theft, compared to 19% of all respondents,” Equifax said.

“Additionally, younger adults surveyed stated that they are less likely to use up-to-date anti-virus protection for their computers (61% versus 72% of the general population).”

Source CMP
By Ephraim Vecina

30 Oct

Could the Bank of Canada raise interest rates again in 2023?

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

The Bank of Canada struck a “hawkish tone” in its latest policy rate announcement that points to the possibility of another rate hike if the situation calls for it, according to Sherry Cooper, chief economist at Dominion Lending Centres (DLC).

Cooper acknowledged the slowdown in economic activity since late 2022, which has “dramatically reduced” demand since then.

“The output gap–the difference between the actual growth in GDP and its potential growth at full employment–is essentially closed, suggesting that demand pressures have been easing,” she noted. “[The BoC] had previously expected the output gap to close in early 2024.”

At the same time, Cooper is anticipating the central bank to aim for a delicate balance in its coming policy announcements.

“The bank does not want to boost interest-sensitive spending, such as housing and durable goods purchases, by assuring markets that its next move will be a rate cut,” Cooper said.

Coupled with inflation remaining sticky at levels much higher than the BoC’s 2% target, Cooper is expecting the policy status quo to persist for a prolonged period.

“I expect the bank to pause rate hikes for the next six to nine months,” she said. “When they finally begin to ease monetary policy, they will do so gradually, taking the overnight rate down to roughly 4% by the end of next year.”

Elevated inflation likely to persist, BoC head says

Bank of Canada governor Tiff Macklem recently said that further interest rate hikes are still on the table due to sustained inflationary pressures.

“Our 2% target is now in sight… [but] monetary policy still has work to do to restore price stability for Canadians, and we are committed to staying the course,” Macklem said.

Data from Statistics Canada showed that the annualized pace of inflation posted a small drop to 3.7% in September.

“Overall inflationary pressures are persisting and larger-than-normal price increases remain broad-based across the goods and services Canadians buy regularly,” Macklem said.

Source CMP
By Ephraim Vecina

26 Oct

Is the Bank of Canada done with rate hikes?

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

The Bank of Canada indicated yesterday that it’s prepared to raise interest rates again if required – but its acknowledgement that the economy is slowing substantially is a positive sign, according to Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) deputy chief economist Benjamin Tal.

The central bank left its policy rate untouched for a second consecutive month in its October 25 decision, holding that trendsetting rate steady at 5.0% while also emphasizing that further rate hikes could be on the cards.

Still, its optimistic tone on the labour market – where it said job vacancies and employment gains were easing – suggested it believes it can afford to leave rates where they are barring major negative developments, according to Tal.

“They maintained hawkish language which makes sense, because… this is a biased bank,” he told Canadian Mortgage Professional. “They just cannot keep you relaxed about interest rates. They have to keep you guessing. That’s exactly what they’re doing: they’re admitting that the economy is slowing down, and that’s a good thing.

“Overall, I think [the decision is] no big surprise. It’s a Bank that’s willing to raise again if needed. The focus is inflation, the focus is the labour market – but they admit that the past hikes in interest rates are impacting the economy.”

Could stickier-than-expected inflation prompt another rate hike?

The central bank’s 10 rate hikes since March 2022, which have spiked its benchmark rate by 475 basis points, are “dampening economic activity and relieving price pressures,” it said in its Wednesday statement.

However, inflation remains a significant concern, with the Bank noting that its preferred measures of core inflation do not appear to be ticking downwards. It still expects consumer price index (CPI) inflation to hit its 2% target in 2025 – but next year is now projected to see higher inflation than previously anticipated, averaging around 3.5% through the middle of next year.

Tal said the Bank is probably striking a mostly cautionary tone on inflation, with current trends unlikely to convince it a further rate increase is required.

“I don’t think that at this point they’re ready to raise interest rates on that,” he said. “I think they realize that it’s a lagging indicator and it takes time for it to slow down. [They’re] focusing totally on the labour market, and there are clear signs that the labour market is tight, starting to move in the right direction.

“If you look at the quit rate, if you look at vacancies, they’re falling very quickly, so I think they realize that it’s just a question of time until this will be translated into the labour market and wage pressure. I think they’re willing to wait at this point but in the language, they cannot tell you that. In the language, they will have to remain hawkish.”

Tal and CIBC believe the Bank of Canada will begin cutting rates in the middle of 2024, and that its benchmark rate will probably end up at around 3% by the end of 2025.

What’s next for the housing market?

The Bank’s pause on rate hikes earlier this year spurred something of a national housing market revival, one that was swiftly quelled by back-to-back increases in June and July.

A repeat is unlikely to play out despite its rate remaining unchanged for the last two announcements, Tal said.

“I don’t see a surge in activity, quite frankly,” he said. “I think that it will be different between the first pause, that was in January of this year, and this pause. I think that the market is bruised enough from this increase in interest rates.”

The Bank highlighted the impact on the economy of a surge in Canada’s population, which it said was helping ease labour market pressures in certain sectors while also contributing to higher consumption and housing demand.

“The question is whether or not new immigrants and newcomers are inflationary,” Tal said. “On the one hand, they’re adding to supply of labour and therefore reducing wage pressure. On the other hand, they consume.

“I think at the margins, they are inflationary in the short period of time and the Bank of Canada knows that we would have been in a recession without the increase in immigration. So they have to recognize this very huge contributor.”

Overall, Tal said despite the Bank’s continually aggressive stance on the prospect of further rate hikes, its October statement contained some encouraging indicators that the end may be in sight.

“At the end of the day, we have to remember that this is a biased bank, so the language will be hawkish regardless of what they do,” he said. “But they started to indicate that the economy is slowing, which is good [and] very important. It’s an indication that they know it’s just a question of time.”

Source CMP
By Fergal McAlinden

25 Oct

Bank of Canada reveals October rate decision

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

The central bank has made its second-to-last scheduled rate announcement of the year.

The Bank of Canada has left its policy interest rate unchanged in its latest decision, opting not to raise rates further amid signs that the national economy is beginning to slow.

The central bank announced this morning that it was holding that trendsetting interest rate steady at 5.0%, the second time in a row it has kept rates where they are as inflation continues to moderate and economic growth remains largely flat.

In its statement accompanying the decision, the Bank said it was prepared to raise the policy rate further if required, emphasizing its concern that “progress towards price stability is slow and inflationary risks have increased.”

Overall inflation slowed more dramatically in September than markets had expected, to 3.8%, while gross domestic product (GDP) growth also moderated noticeably towards the end of the summer.

Despite its stated concern over inflation, those factors evidently helped convince the central bank, which has already raised interest rates 10 times to the tune of 475 basis points since March 2022, that its strategy aimed at tamping down inflation and cooling the economy was proving largely effective.

Move comes as little surprise to markets

Markets had widely expected the Bank to announce no change in this month’s announcement, its penultimate scheduled decision on interest rates for 2023. Odds of an October hike plunged from 43% to 13% on the back of the latest inflation data, according to Reuters.

The move isn’t expected to have a significant impact on Canada’s housing market, with activity having already slowed considerably since the beginning of the central bank’s rate-hiking path.

Ahead of the Bank decision, RE/MAX Canada president Christopher Alexander told Canadian Mortgage Professional a pause “isn’t going to sway activity one way or another.”

Current high interest rates, he said, have already weighed down heavily on demand and pushed many would-be buyers out of the market.

The Bank of Canada is scheduled to announce its final decision on interest rates for 2023 on December 6.

Source CMP
By Fergal McAlinden

24 Oct

Will Canada enter a recession?

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

Canada will narrowly avoid an outright recession, but the central bank’s multi-decade-high interest rates will likely restrict economic growth down to near-zero levels for a prolonged period, according to the consensus of economists recently polled by Bloomberg.

The poll, which was conducted from October 13-18, also found that Canadian GDP will be essentially flat in the fourth quarter, only slightly ticking up to a 0.3% annualized pace by Q1 2024.

“Both figures are a downgrade from the previous month’s survey, and project growth that’s well below the rate at which Canada’s population is increasing,” Bloomberg said in its release of the poll results.

The Bank of Canada’s elevated interest rates are expected to do their job in reining in runaway inflation, with the pace anticipated to settle at 3.3% in Q1 2024 and then retreat further to 2.1% in the second half of the year.

Economists’ consensus pegged the first BoC rate cuts occurring in the second quarter of 2024, albeit at a languid pace.

The poll’s median prediction for the central bank’s benchmark policy rate is at 4% by the end of end of next year, versus the previous consensus for 3.75%.

North America’s central banks likely to pare down rates beginning 2024

A recent analysis by Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) projected that North American central banks are likely to make their first cuts next year, although rates are also as likely to remain higher than pre-pandemic levels to keep inflation pressures in check.

“We have argued before that there are good reasons to think that an era of unusually cheap money has come to an end,” RBC said. “That doesn’t mean interest rates will stay at today’s levels – most central bankers still view the level of interest rates currently as ‘restrictive.’

“For now, the aggressive run-up in interest rates since early 2022 means central banks are no longer in catch up mode and additional interest rate moves are highly data dependent [in the near-term].”

Source CMP
By Ephraim Vecina

24 Oct

What will the Bank of Canada do this week?

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

The Bank of Canada is widely expected to hold its key interest rate steady on Wednesday as the Canadian economy bends to higher interest rates and inflation resumes its downward trend.

The central bank held its key interest rate steady at 5% last month but kept the door open to more rate hikes, citing concerns about the persistence of underlying price pressures.

“Economic data releases since the Bank of Canada opted to forego an interest rate hike in September have been mixed, but we expect that they on net have made a hike at next week’s decision unlikely,” wrote RBC assistant chief economist Nathan Janzen and economist Claire Fan in a client note on Friday.

The annual inflation rate rose in both July and August, while core measures of inflation – which strip out volatile prices – have not eased by much in recent months.

But the September consumer price index report helped quell some of those anxieties as the pace of price growth slowed across the economy and the annual inflation rate fell back to 3.8%.

“We were kind of breathing a sigh of relief a little bit after the last inflation numbers,” said Andrew Grantham, CIBC executive director of economics.

“The recent inflation numbers suggest that it is starting to decelerate once again. And that, combined with the sluggish growth that we’ve seen, will probably keep (the Bank of Canada) on hold, not just this meeting, but really for the remainder of this year, and into next year as well.”

The Canadian economy shrank in the second quarter. Economists anticipate that weakness will continue for the rest of the year and into 2024.

The Bank of Canada’s recent business outlook survey supported this expectation. It showed business sentiment continued to weaken in the third quarter as companies said they expect sales growth to slow over the coming year.

On the jobs front, employment continues to rise as Canada’s population keeps surging, but the job market is not as robust as it was in 2022. Job vacancies have fallen and the unemployment rate has edged higher to 5.5%.

The pace of consumer spending has also slowed. New retail Canadian retail sales fell 0.1% to $66.1 billion in August as sales at new and used car dealers fell for the month, Statistics Canada said Friday.

These trends are expected to continue as the effect of previous rate hikes take hold on the economy, pinching the pocketbooks of more Canadians and businesses.

In particular, as more households renew their mortgages, the effect of higher interest rates is expected to weigh on more people.

“We know that there’s more to come because we know that actually, fewer than 50% of mortgage holders in Canada have been exposed to higher interest rates,” said Grantham.

Ontario Premier Doug Ford sounded a similar note of caution in letters he sent to both Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Sunday.

The letter to Macklem marked the second time Ford reached out to directly ask the bank to hold off on further rate increases, but Sunday’s correspondence focused more explicitly on the effect recent hikes have already had on mortgage costs.

“Every week, I hear directly from families that are paying hundreds or even thousands of dollars more each month on their mortgages,” the letter reads. “This is an additional expense that ordinary families cannot afford, forcing them to choose between essentials like groceries, fuel, and shelter. While you have said that these crushing increases are necessary to combat inflation, that justification is wearing thin.”

Ford’s letter to Trudeau asked the Prime Minister to work with provinces and territories to address the root causes of inflation.

Most economists expect the current weaker economic and tighter financial conditions to eventually bring inflation back down to 2%.

And while sticky core inflation is likely still a concern for the Bank of Canada, Grantham expects that concern to factor into the central bank’s decision on when to cut rates, rather than whether rates should rise further.

On the international front, the global economy faces some uncertainty amid the Israel-Hamas war, which risks destabilizing the Middle East.

“We’re seeing, globally, the risks around inflation have risen. The conflict in the Middle East, if that escalates, you know, wars are inflationary. There’s no other way around it,” Grantham said.

Central banks know all too well what wars can do to prices: the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 contributed significantly to the initial inflation runup as commodity prices skyrocketed.

Last week, Macklem said it was too early to tell what the economic repercussions of the Israel-Hamas war may be.

“It’s far too early to tell. And it really depends on to what extent this escalates,” Macklem said.

The Bank of Canada’s rate decision will be accompanied by its quarterly monetary policy report, which includes updated forecasts for global and domestic economies as well as for inflation.

Source CMP
By Nojoud Al Mallees

20 Oct

How busy will Canada’s mortgage and housing markets be in 2024?

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

Canada’s mortgage and housing markets have seen plenty of turbulence throughout this year amid climbing interest rates and cooler sales activity – but while challenges will persist in 2024, there’s room for optimism looking ahead.

That was the message from a panel at this week’s Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC) national conference in Toronto, convening top executives from leading lenders to hear their thoughts on how the market is likely to play out next year.

While a dramatic turnaround isn’t in the cards for Canada’s still-tepid housing market, opportunity will still present itself in 2024, according to participants in the panel – moderated by Canada Guaranty senior vice president of sales and marketing Mary Putnam.

Marina Bournas, RFA Mortgage Corporation’s president and chief executive officer, highlighted the cyclical nature of the mortgage market, and said her company was looking to the future with a positive outlook.

“I think we’re in an industry where it comes in ebbs and flows, and we’ve been through multiple changes: there have been regulatory changes, market changes,” she said. “So I’m an optimist.

“With that being said, I do think 2024 will probably look very similar to 2023, and hopefully there’s some optimism with rates for the latter part of the year.”

Top of mind for RFA at present, according to Bournas, is gearing up for busier times ahead by strengthening existing relationships and adding new talent.

“We’re trying to ensure we’re working on the foundation, working on continuing to build that trust with our brokers,” she said, “working to hire and train and just be ready when it starts up again – because it absolutely will.”

Certainty on interest rates required before market shifts again

Yousry Bissada, CEO of Home Trust Company, told the audience that while demand was still definitely present in the housing market, buyers and sellers alike required clarity on when interest rates are likely to fall before stepping back into the fray.

“The fear of this uncertainty and volatility that’s going on, we believe, still left a lot of people on the sidelines,” he said. “And that may last a while yet. People just need a little certainty… People need to know that the Bank of Canada will one day say, ‘We’re done, and we’re on the way down.’

“And when that happens, I think people get certainty, and they’re willing to put money in and they’re willing to risk what a renewal will look like a few years down the road.”

The end result? “I think it’s going to be very similar to this year,” Bissada added, “especially with the backup as people just remain on the sidelines and wait to see, wait for that announcement of ‘We’re done.’”

A subdued market for now – but green shoots emerging

Jason Ellis, First National Financial’s president and CEO, said that while the market would likely remain subdued in 2024, there appeared to be little prospect of a sizeable downturn, particularly with demand always persisting among Canadian homebuyers.

“I think we’re going to be fine. I think origination volumes will moderate,” he said. “I don’t think we’re going to go off the housing cliff – I still think there’s a great deal of resiliency. And we’ve got that backdrop of [the] supply problem, which means there’s always going to be buyers of houses.”

BMO head of home financing and personal lending Hassan Pirnia reinforced the notion of a market that goes through cycles – and said that while further moderation of prices and activity could be ahead, the housing sector was nevertheless poised to rebound mildly after that.

“Despite what we’ve experienced in recent years… we’re in a cyclical business,” he said. “There are peaks and valleys, and we are still in the valley. So our prediction is it’s going to be a moderate housing slump, and it will recalibrate in mid- to late 2024, when the interest rates will start coming down.”

Source CMP
By Fergal McAlinden

19 Oct

CIBC fined over mortgage discharge rules violation

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

It is the fourth of Canada’s five major banks to face penalties for such violations this year

Consumer Protection BC, British Columbia’s consumer protection agency, has fined Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) over $3.4 million after it was found to have violated mortgage discharge rules.

According to the regulator, CIBC did not comply with its obligations in properly discharging mortgages upon sales.

“Consumer Protection BC’s recent assessment of the financial sector’s compliance with provincial consumer protection laws showed that there is broad non-compliance when it comes to the requirement to provide a consumer with a discharge document within 30 days of a mortgage loan being paid in full,” the agency stated last July.

According to the law, a mortgage lender needs to provide borrowers with a discharge document so the Land Title and Survey Authority of British Columbia can clear the property title. The maximum fee that a lender can charge for this is $75 in British Columbia.

Should a homeowner sell their home with money owed on the mortgage, either a lawyer or a notary will be vital in achieving a discharge as they take the money from the buyer and pay the lender while the leftover money will go to the seller. As this occurred, the bank will need to provide the discharge document to the borrower and land title office.

Consumer Protection BC said that investigations were launched after the Law Society of BC, Society of Notaries Public of BC, and Land Title and Survey Authority of British Columbia expressed their concerns.

CIBC will need to show the regulator that its standard residential mortgages had been paid out in the period of time it was investigated, between January 1, 2018 and April 1, 2022.

Ron Usher, the lead counsel for the Society of Notaries Public of BC, monitored the issues for years and said that he had seen the deterioration of compliance even as there was a high-profile fraud case that was aided by undischarged mortgages.

CIBC becomes the fourth out of the five major banks in Canada to be fined for this type of violation this year. The biggest penalty was issued to TD Canada Trust ($5.3 million) while Scotiabank ($387,150), Bank of Montreal ($132,700), and HSBC ($305,900) were also fined for their failure to discharge mortgages within 30 days of a mortgage loan being fully paid.

Other banks, credit unions, or financial institutions that have also been fined include First National Financial GP Corporation ($29,200), Coast Capital Savings ($47,900), Vancouver City Savings Credit Union ($86,300), First West Credit Union ($14,000), and Prospera Credit Union ($8,800).

Source CMP
By Abigail Adriatico

18 Oct

Annual pace of housing starts rises in September

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

The annual pace of housing starts was up by 8% in September compared with the previous month, according to the national housing agency.

Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) said on Wednesday that September saw a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 270,466 units in September, a jump from 250,383 the previous month that was driven mainly by a quicker pace of urban housing starts.

Those starts were up 9% on a month-over-month basis, according to CMHC, while the annual pace of multi-unit urban starts accelerated by 10% to 207,689 units.

The rate of single-detached urban starts increased slightly, rising by 3% to 43,077 units last month, while the annual rate of rural starts came in at 19,700 units.

Stronger homebuilding activity last month came as a welcome change from August, when the trend in housing starts came in largely flat – rising only 0.8% on a monthly basis.

Source CMP
By Fergal McAlinden

17 Oct

Good News On the Inflation Front Suggests Policy Rates Have Peaked

General

Posted by: Mike Hattim

Today’s inflation report for September was considerably better than expected, ending the three-month rise in inflation. Not only did the headline inflation rate fall, but so did the core measures of inflation on a year-over-year basis and a three-month moving average basis. This, in combination with the weak Business Outlook Survey released yesterday, suggests that the overnight policy rate at 5% may be the peak in rates. While I do not expect the Bank to begin cutting rates until the middle of next year, the worst of the tightening cycle may well be over.

Offsetting the deceleration in the all-items CPI was a year-over-year increase in gasoline prices, which rose faster in September (+7.5%) compared with August (+0.8%) due to a base-year effect. Excluding gasoline, the CPI rose 3.7% in September, following a 4.1% increase in August. Looking ahead to the October inflation report, the base effect for headline CPI is favourable, as CPI surged in October 2022. Gasoline prices are down about 7% so far this month. Given the war in the Middle East, however, there is no guarantee that this will hold, but if it does, the October headline CPI could move into the low-3% range.

On a monthly basis, the CPI fell 0.1% in September after a 0.4% gain in August. The monthly slowdown was mainly driven by lower month-over-month prices for gasoline (-1.3%) in September. Goods inflation fell 0.3% from a month earlier, the first time since December 2022, and grew 3.6% from a year ago versus 3.7% in August. Services inflation was unchanged from August, the first time it hasn’t grown on a monthly basis since November 2021, while the rate slowed to 3.9% on a yearly basis, from 4.3% in August.

Yesterday’s Survey of Consumer Expectations showed that perceptions of current inflation remain well above actual inflation.  One reason is the very visible level of grocery and gasoline prices. As the chart below shows, food inflation–though still elevated–decelerated to 5.9% last month, and CPI excluding food and energy fell to a cycle-low 2.8%. Large monthly gains in September 2022, when grocery prices increased at the fastest pace in 41 years, fell out of the 12-month movements and put downward pressure on the indexes.
Prices for durable goods rose at a slower pace year over year in September (+0.4%) compared with August (+1.4%). The purchase of new passenger vehicles index contributed the most to the slowdown, rising 1.7% year over year in September, following a 3.1% gain in August. The deceleration in the price of new passenger vehicles was partly attributable to improved inventory levels compared with a year ago.

Additionally, furniture prices (-4.6%) and household appliances (-2.3%) continued to decline year-over-year in September, contributing to the slowdown in durable goods. Consumers paid less on a year-over-year basis for air transportation (-21.1 %) in September, coinciding with a gradual increase in airline flights over the previous 12 months.

Other measures of core inflation followed by the Bank of Canada also decelerated.

Bottom Line

According to Bloomberg News calculations, “A three-month moving average of underlying price pressures that Governor Tiff Macklem has flagged as key to policymakers’ thinking fell to an annualized pace of 3.67%, from 4.29% a month earlier.”  While this is still well above the Bank’s 2% target, the global economy is slowing, the Canadian and US economies are slowing, and with any luck at all, the Bank of Canada might see inflation move to within its target range next year. However, the central bank will be cautious, refraining from rate cuts until the middle of next year. The full impact of rate hikes has yet to be felt. The next move by the Bank of Canada could be a rate cut, but not until next year.

Dr. Sherry Cooper